In 1962 the present site in Kendal Avenue was purchased and the “huts” moved to that site while plans for a permanent church went ahead, culminating in the opening of St Timothy’s in 1963 as a daughter church of St Aidan’s. It was a rather spartan building at the outset, but this did not stem the enthusiasm of the parishioners dedicated to proclaiming their faith with joy and song. Improvements and extensions to the building soon followed and in 1970 the Rev John Greenslade was appointed the first vicar of the Parish of Burnside. St Timothy’s was consecrated debt-free on 5 April 1994.
In 1966 St James' combined with the newly built A-frame church in Bishopdale to form the Mission District of Bishopdale-Harewood. This was a happy mix of the established Harewood families and the young and enthusiastic families of the new district of Bishopdale. Unfortunately enthusiasm was not enough to financially support two small churches, so in 1983 St Timothy’s incorporated St James' into the thriving Parish of Burnside. The association of the two churches worked well, adding to the already wide range of worship and activities within the Parish, later renamed “The Parish of Burnside-Harewood.”